The Book in the order it was written
The Book → Threads

Why do the innocent suffer?

The collection states a rule, then spends centuries attacking it. This is the clearest case of these texts arguing with one another rather than agreeing.

  1. IIIc. 700-587 BCE
    Deuteronomy · Chapter 28
    1 It shall happen, if you shall listen diligently to Yahweh your God’s voice, to observe to do all his commandments which I command you today, that Yahweh your God will set you high above all the nations of the earth.
    15 But it shall come to pass, if you will not listen to Yahweh your God’s voice, to observe to do all his commandments and his statutes which I command you today, that all these curses will come on you and overtake you.

    The rule, stated as plainly as it ever gets: obey and be blessed, disobey and be cursed. Much of the collection assumes this, and much of the rest exists to dispute it.

  2. IIIc. 700-587 BCE
    Habakkuk · Chapter 1
    13 You who have purer eyes than to see evil, and who cannot look on perversity, why do you tolerate those who deal treacherously and keep silent when the wicked swallows up the man who is more righteous than he,

    Late seventh century. A prophet accuses God directly of watching treachery and doing nothing. The complaint is in scripture, not answered from outside it.

  3. V539 - c. 400 BCE
    Job · Chapter 21
    7 “Why do the wicked live, become old, yes, and grow mighty in power?

    Job takes the rule and inverts it with the evidence: the wicked grow old and powerful. His friends defend the rule for thirty chapters and God tells them at the end that they were wrong and Job was right.

  4. V539 - c. 400 BCE
    Psalms · Chapter 73
    2 But as for me, my feet were almost gone. My steps had nearly slipped.
    3 For I was envious of the arrogant, when I saw the prosperity of the wicked.
    16 When I tried to understand this, it was too painful for me—
    17 until I entered God’s sanctuary, and considered their latter end.

    Psalm 73 admits the writer nearly lost his footing over this, and resolves it only by going into the sanctuary — an answer that is honest about being a change of vantage rather than an argument.

  5. VIc. 400-200 BCE
    Ecclesiastes · Chapter 8
    14 There is a vanity which is done on the earth, that there are righteous men to whom it happens according to the work of the wicked. Again, there are wicked men to whom it happens according to the work of the righteous. I said that this also is vanity.

    The bleakest verse on the subject, and it was kept: righteous men get what the wicked deserve, and wicked men get what the righteous deserve.

  6. VIIIc. 100 BCE - 50 CE
    The Wisdom of Solomon · Chapter 3
    1 But the souls of the righteous are in the hand of God, and no torment will touch them.
    2 In the eyes of the foolish they seemed to have died. Their departure was considered a disaster,
    4 For even if in the sight of men they are punished, their hope is full of immortality.

    A resolution arrives, and it arrives only once an afterlife does: the righteous seemed to die, but they are at peace. The problem is answered by moving the accounting past death.

  7. IXc. 50-110 CE
    John · Chapter 9
    2 His disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”
    3 Jesus answered, “This man didn’t sin, nor did his parents, but that the works of God might be revealed in him.

    Asked whose sin caused a man's blindness, Jesus rejects the premise of the question outright. The retribution rule is denied to its face.

  8. IXc. 50-110 CE
    Romans · Chapter 8
    18 For I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which will be revealed toward us.
    28 We know that all things work together for good for those who love God, for those who are called according to his purpose.

    Paul does not explain suffering away. He argues that it is not the last word and not worth comparing to what follows — a claim about the ending, not a solution to the problem.

No stop here cancels the others. Deuteronomy's rule is still in the book that contains Job's refutation of it, and Ecclesiastes' flat observation that the same fate meets everyone was never edited out. A collection assembled to reassure would not have kept all three. Whatever else that means, it means the people who preserved these texts were willing to preserve the objection.

The passages above are the text, reproduced exactly and checked against the same files the reader uses; every reference is verified when the site is built. The commentary between them is editorial, written for this volume.

Open in the reader All the threads